Outsourced vs. Co-Sourced Internal Audit: Choosing the Right Model

Outsourced internal audit means an external firm serves as your internal audit function; co-sourced internal audit means an external firm supplements an in-house team with capacity or specialist skills. The right model depends on your size, risk profile, budget and need for specialized expertise such as IT audit.

Every organization that answers to a board, lenders, regulators or investors benefits from independent assurance that risks are understood and controls work. The question is how to staff that assurance. There are three common models — in-house, outsourced and co-sourced — and many organizations move between them as they grow.

The three models

In-house. The organization employs its own internal audit staff, led by a Chief Audit Executive (CAE) who reports functionally to the audit committee.

Outsourced. An external firm serves as the internal audit function. The provider typically develops the risk assessment and audit plan, performs the audits and reports to the audit committee, with a designated internal executive providing oversight.

Co-sourced. An in-house team, led by the CAE, partners with an external firm that provides additional capacity or specialized skills on specific audits — commonly IT audit, cybersecurity, data analytics or industry expertise.

Comparing the options

In-house Outsourced Co-sourced
Cost structure Fixed salaries and overhead Variable, based on audit plan Mix of fixed and variable
Specialist skills Hard to maintain internally Available from provider Added where needed
Institutional knowledge Highest Builds over time with continuity Retained by in-house team
Flexibility Limited High High
Best fit Large organizations with steady demand Small and mid-sized organizations Organizations with a core team and specialist gaps

When outsourcing makes sense

  • You're establishing internal audit for the first time, perhaps prompted by growth, a board request, an IPO or lender requirements.
  • Your audit needs don't justify several full-time positions with the right mix of skills.
  • You need financial, operational and IT audit coverage but can't hire all three.
  • You want an experienced team that can start quickly.

When co-sourcing makes sense

  • You have a capable in-house team but lack IT audit, cybersecurity or data analytics expertise.
  • Your workload is seasonal — for example, SOX testing peaks.
  • You need industry-specific knowledge for particular audits.
  • You want to develop your team by working alongside specialists.

Governance doesn't change

Whatever the model, governance responsibilities remain with the organization. The IIA's Global Internal Audit Standards, effective January 9, 2025, place strong emphasis on the board's oversight of internal audit and on the function's mandate, charter, strategy and quality. When outsourcing, make sure:

  • The internal audit charter defines the provider's role and reporting lines
  • A designated executive is responsible for overseeing the provider
  • The audit committee approves the risk assessment and audit plan
  • The provider follows the IIA Standards and maintains a quality assurance program
  • Independence is preserved — the provider shouldn't audit work it performed for management

Choosing a provider

Look for a firm with relevant industry experience, both financial and IT audit expertise, a defined methodology aligned with the IIA Standards, continuity of staff from year to year and reporting your audit committee will find clear and useful. And remember: your external financial statement auditor is generally not permitted to perform your internal audit.

The bottom line

The best internal audit model is the one that gives your board credible, risk-focused assurance at a sustainable cost. Outsourcing provides a complete function quickly; co-sourcing fills specific gaps. Many organizations start with one and evolve to the other as they grow.

Frequently asked questions

Is outsourced internal audit cheaper than in-house?

Often, for small and mid-sized organizations. You pay for the audit hours you need rather than full-time salaries, and you gain access to specialists without hiring them. Larger organizations with steady demand may find in-house staff more economical for routine work.

Can our external auditor perform our internal audit?

For public companies and many others, independence rules prohibit the financial statement auditor from providing internal audit outsourcing services. Use a separate firm.

What does a Chief Audit Executive do in an outsourced model?

An organization should designate someone responsible for overseeing the internal audit function. In an outsourced model, the provider's engagement leader often performs many CAE activities, while a designated executive and the audit committee retain oversight.

Sources and further reading

  1. The IIA: Global Internal Audit Standards

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal, accounting or other professional advice. Requirements change; consult the cited sources and a qualified advisor about your specific situation.

Formos Consulting Risk, compliance, cybersecurity and transformation advisors

Keep reading

Related insights

All insights

Let’s talk about what you need.

Tell us where you are and where you need to be. A senior member of our team will follow up to talk through options.